Cookies That
Steal the Show
Every Single Time
Handcrafted cookies and show-stopping cookie cakes — made from scratch with seasonal ingredients and personalized for every occasion.
50+
Happy Customers
10+
Cookie Flavors
5★
Average Rating
Cookies Are What We Do
Handcrafted cookies and cookie cakes made from scratch with the finest ingredients — plus a few other treats we love to make on the side.
Cookies
Our Flagship — Edible Art in Every Bite
This is where the magic lives. From classic brown butter chocolate chip to hand-decorated frosted sugar cookies — every cookie is baked from scratch with real ingredients and a whole lot of love.
Frosted Sugar Cookies
Classic soft sugar cookies topped with a generous layer of smooth, sweet frosting — perfect for any occasion
Brown Butter Choc Chip
Nutty browned butter dough loaded with gooey chocolate chips, crisp edges and chewy center, finished with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt
Double Chocolate
Rich dark chocolate cookie dough with extra chocolate chips — for the true chocoholic
Snickerdoodle
Soft, pillowy cookies rolled in cinnamon sugar with a perfectly crinkled top
Biscoff
Buttery cookie dough swirled with Biscoff spread, topped with a whole Biscoff cookie and drizzled with white chocolate
S'mores Cookie
Chocolate cookie base topped with a toasted marshmallow, graham cracker pieces, and a chocolate drizzle — campfire vibes in every bite
More Treats We Love to Bake
Cookies are our thing — but we still make a few other favorites for those who ask.
Baking since age 10
Started with an Easy-Bake Oven
Certified
Entrepreneurship & Small Business
It Started with an
Easy-Bake Oven
I want people to fall in love with baking — the same way my mom made me fall in love with it.
When I was 10, my mom got me an Easy-Bake Oven for my birthday. A few days before, I had watched her bake my birthday cake from scratch — and something about that moment just stuck with me. I wanted to do exactly what she did.
What started as a hobby slowly became a passion. Now, baking out of College Station, TX, I pour that same love into every cookie and cookie cake I make. My goal is simple — I want every person who tries one of my treats to feel that same spark my mom gave me.
A little honesty goes a long way
I'll be real with you — traditional cakes are not my strong suit. I'm totally open to making them, but just know going in that they're probably not going to be Pinterest-perfect. Where I truly work my magic is cookies and cookie cakes — that's where every bite speaks for itself. Giant decorated cookie cakes and layered cookie cakes are my jam, and they're honestly way more fun than a traditional cake anyway. I'd rather be upfront than have you expect something I can't deliver!
Inspired by Mom
It all started watching my mom bake my birthday cake. That moment sparked a love for baking I've carried ever since.
Made from Scratch
Every single item is handcrafted in small batches with real ingredients — no shortcuts, ever.
Proudly Local
Based in College Station, TX — baking for the community I love, one order at a time.
Entrepreneurship & Small Business Certified
Formally certified in Entrepreneurship and Small Business — bringing professionalism and dedication to every order.
Ordering is as Easy as
Eating the Cookie
From first message to first bite — here's how it works.
Tell Peyton Your Vision
Fill out the order form with your occasion, flavors, colors, and any inspiration. The more detail, the better!
Get a Personal Reply
Peyton responds within 48 hours to confirm details and finalize pricing.
Watch the Magic Happen
Every item is baked fresh from scratch using seasonal ingredients — no shortcuts, no compromises.
Pick Up or Get Delivered
Collect your beautifully packaged treats at pickup or have them delivered locally. Ready to wow.
Seasonal Ingredients
Fresh, local, and in-season
Fully Handcrafted
No shortcuts
Custom Designs
Your vision, brought to life
Satisfaction Guaranteed
Peyton stands behind every bake
Ready to make it official?
Spots are limited — don't miss your date. Order takes 2 minutes.
A Peek Inside
the Bakery
Every creation is a little work of art. Follow along on Instagram for daily baking inspiration.
Kind Words from
Real Customers
“Cookies and cake pops were delicious! The attention to detail and packaging were very impressive. We will definitely be ordering again soon!”
Lyndi Birkhead
Verified Customer
Loved Every Bite?
Tell Us About It
Your feedback means the world! If you've ordered from Baked by Peyton, we'd love to hear what you thought. Real reviews from real customers help others know what to expect — and help Peyton keep doing what she loves.
It means a lot
Every review helps a small business grow and reach more dessert lovers.
Real people only
No fake reviews here — only honest words from actual customers.
Takes 30 seconds
Just a star rating and a few words about your experience is perfect.
Frequently Asked
Questions
Everything you need to know before placing your order. Can't find your answer? Reach out through the order form below!
How do I place a custom order?
Fill out the Custom Order form on this page with your occasion, desired treats, quantity, and any design inspiration. Peyton will follow up within 48 hours to confirm details and pricing. Full payment is due at pickup or delivery.
What information do you need for a custom order?
The more detail the better! Share your occasion (birthday, wedding, holiday, etc.), flavor preferences, color palette or theme, quantity needed, and your pickup/delivery date. Inspiration photos are always welcome and super helpful.
Do you have a minimum order size?
For custom decorated cookies, the minimum is one dozen (12 cookies). Cookie cakes are ordered individually with no minimum — pick your size and we'll make it happen. Cinnamon rolls are available in half-dozen (6) or full-dozen (12) packs.
Can I order standard (non-custom) treats?
Yes! Peyton occasionally offers ready-to-order seasonal treats through Instagram. Follow @baked_by_peyton to catch those drops. For guaranteed availability, a custom order is always the best route.
What payment methods do you accept?
Venmo, Zelle, and cash are all accepted. Full payment is due at pickup or before delivery.
How far in advance should I order?
For custom decorated cookies and cookie cakes, please order at least 2 weeks in advance. Cinnamon rolls and pies need a minimum of 5–7 days notice. For weddings or large events, 4–6 weeks ahead is strongly recommended to guarantee your date.
Can you accommodate rush orders?
Rush orders (less than the standard lead time) may be possible depending on Peyton's current schedule. A rush fee of 20% will apply. Reach out as soon as possible and she'll do her best to make it happen!
How long do your treats stay fresh?
Decorated cookies stay fresh for up to 2 weeks at room temperature in their sealed packaging. Cookie cakes are best enjoyed within 3–4 days. Cinnamon rolls are best enjoyed within 2–3 days and can be reheated. Pies keep for 3–4 days refrigerated. Freezing instructions are included with every order.
What happens if I need to cancel or reschedule?
Life happens! Reschedules are welcome with at least 1 week's notice at no extra charge. For cancellations, please give as much notice as possible. If Peyton needs to cancel for any reason, you'll be notified right away.
Where is pickup located?
Pickup is available at Peyton's home kitchen. The exact address is shared once your order is confirmed. Pickup windows are typically scheduled on weekends or by appointment during the week.
Do you offer delivery?
Delivery is available with a minimum fee of $5. If you're located outside of College Station, please reach out to inquire about pricing — rates vary based on distance. Delivery is available Thursday through Sunday.
Can you ship treats?
Decorated cookies are the only item currently available for shipping, as they travel the best. Unfortunately, cookie cakes cannot be shipped due to their size and frosting decorations. Shipping is available within the continental US for cookies only. Orders must be placed at least 3 weeks in advance for shipped orders.
How should I transport my order?
Keep your treats flat and away from direct sunlight or heat. Cookies travel best at room temperature. Cookie cakes should be transported on a flat, level surface — especially the layered ones! Peyton packages everything securely, but careful driving is always appreciated!
Still have questions?
Peyton loves hearing from you. Drop a message through the order form or DM on Instagram.
Ready to Sweeten
Your Celebration?
Custom orders are available for weddings, birthdays, baby showers, holidays, and any special moment worth celebrating. Fill out the form and Peyton will be in touch within 48 hours!
Payment at Pickup or Delivery
No payment needed upfront — your full balance is due when you receive your order. Peyton will confirm your total before your pickup or delivery date.
Order Lead Time
Please allow 5–7 days for custom orders. Rush orders may be available.
Local Pickup & Delivery
Pickup available in College Station, TX. Local delivery starts at $5. Nationwide shipping available — enter your address for an estimated rate.
Follow for Updates
Check @baked_by_peyton on Instagram for seasonal menus and availability.
Cancellation Policy
Full balance is due at pickup or delivery. Peyton reserves the right to cancel orders that cannot be fulfilled due to scheduling conflicts.
Your Basket
0 items selected
Your basket is empty.
Add some treats to get started!